Research Proposal
I think that this argument is important because people can be aware of why college students do not own hybrid cars. Many people know how expensive they are but they do not know the reason why they are so expensive.
My objective is to be able to make people understand why college students aren’t driving hybrid cars on campus. There have been plenty of times where I walk through the parking lots at IUP and dont see any hybrid cars in sight. These hybrid cars are supposed to be environment friendly and i’m trying to find out why more of these cars aren’t being bought and driven.
Why dont college students drive hybrid cars? Why are these hybrid cars so expensive that only few people can afford them?
Hybrid – an automobile with more than one power source, such as an electric motor and internal combustion engine or an electric motor with battery and fuel cells for energy storage.
My expectations are that people (college students) dont buy hybrid cars because they are too expensive.
Hypothesis – I think that people dont buy hybrids because of the price and also i think that people dont buy them because of the fact that they are fairly new to the automobile market. Being new to the market means that people like to wait to buy things because of recalls and imperfections that the product might have when it is first put out on the market.
Sources:
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/hybrid%20car
Jeffrey Garcia
Professor Harrison
ENGL 202
20 March 2008
Why College Students Don’t Drive Hybrid Cars
Hybrid cars are becoming more popular throughout the United States, but many college students have not chosen to follow this trend. “A hybrid car is an automobile with more than one power source, such as an electric motor and internal combustion engine or an electric motor with battery and fuel cells for energy storage (Dictionary.com).” I chose this topic because the concept of a hybrid car is very interesting to me since I have always had a special interest in cars. When I was young I chose to follow in my fathers footsteps with my love for cars, and have been working around them since a young age. Working on cars has become my number one hobby over the years. I am a junior at Indiana University of Pennsylvania (IUP) majoring in Small Business and Entrepreneurship. Being a full time student, I have chosen not to own a hybrid car for many reasons. They are too expensive to buy and too expensive to fix. Also, paying for a car payment and car insurance is difficult while attending college. After graduation, I plan on opening my own car shop. My passion for cars has led to wonder why, beyond my own reasons, college students do not drive hybrid vehicles.
There have been many times when I have walked around the (IUP) campus and never saw a hybrid car in the parking lot. Hybrid cars are still fairly new to the auto industry, and being fairly new, many of these hybrid cars are very expensive and not everybody can afford them. I want to be able to find out what the demand is for hybrid cars due to the rising gas prices in the United States.
Phillip Dunn (2006) points out that “the tax incentive in the U.S. is another powerful motive – it can reduce your cost up to $3,400 depending on the cost of the vehicle…, the tax break only applies to the first 60,000 vehicles produced yearly by each manufacturer.” This is a good incentive for people to purchase a hybrid car at the beginning of the year in order to save money in a tax break which can lower the cost of the vehicle in the end. I am going to research why these hybrid vehicles are so expensive, and test IUP student’s knowledge of hybrid cars. I will put together a questionnaire so I can ask some college students at IUP about hybrid cars, and determine why IUP college students don’t own hybrid cars. I will also interview a friend who is a junior and she is currently attending IUP also. I will also point out some of the advantages and disadvantages of owning a hybrid car. This topic is important to me because I have come to realize that not too many college students drive hybrid cars and I am unsure of the reasons.
There are some advantages and some disadvantages of owning a hybrid car. The major advantage of a hybrid car is the decreased pollution into the environment. Jim Walczak (2008) states that, “hybrids emit up to 97% less toxic emissions and half as much greenhouse-causing carbon dioxide as the average car.” Another advantage is that the battery pack of a hybrid car does not need to be charged from an external source, it recharges itself through regenerative breaking and from the gasoline engine (4 wheel drive). This shows how convenient a hybrid car can be because the people that own hybrid cars do not have to worry about running out of battery while driving down the highway. These are only some of the advantages of owning a hybrid vehicle.
A key disadvantage is that “they cost more – anywhere from $2000 to $5000 more than non-hybrid version of the same vehicle (4 wheel drive).” This indicates that price is factor that a lot of people think about before buying a hybrid vehicle since they are priced higher than a normal gasoline car. Hybrids can save people gas but, “hybrids have a more complex powertrain, which means more chances of failure and fewer fixes that your mechanic could do,” as stated by Jim Walczak. This proves that it can be more expensive to fix a hybrid vehicle as opposed to a non-hybrid because parts are more expensive and difficult to fix.
As a college student, I know that tuition is very expensive for college students. Many students attend four year colleges and universities and end up having to pay a great deal of money in loans after they graduate. Numerous college students drive cars that might have been their parent’s car before they purchased a new one, and can’t afford to have monthly payments on hybrid cars. Some college students don’t even have the help of their parents to get through college and end up paying every penny of their college education on their own. I am one of those students who have to pay for my own education after graduation from college. I have a wide range of expenses living in college. I pay for everything from books to food to gas in my car and even my own rent. I only have one job, which is three hours away at home and I am only able work when I go home on weekends for about eight hours. Not only do college students have a low income, but they also tend to spend their money in different ways. In this article Crystal McCullough states that, “college students are not only spending money on other fashion savvy clothing but also on fast food and the latest electronics.” This quote explains how college students have other spending habits. College students like to stay up to date when it comes to fashion and having the latest technology gadgets like new cell phones and new IPods. Kay Ahser states that, “college students are notorious for always being broke.” This article explains how college students become broke from spending money on different things. As a college student I know what it is like to be in college and be broke.
Cars have been around for a long time and they have come a long way with technology. “The Baushke family, prominent citizens in Benton Harbor, Michigan and carriage makers by trade, built Americas first car with 4-wheels and seating for 5 people in 1894 (“America’s First Car”).” This quote shows how long ago the first car was built. Cars are now being built to last longer than what they used to before. They are being built with more durable materials and resources. These days, cars have a lot of technology built into them for convenience to the car owners. Some of the technology includes DVD players, Global Positioning System also known as GPS, built in MP3 players, IPod ready receivers and many more parts. A lot of technology means that people are going to pay more money for these new cars.
Phillip Dunn states “the Honda Civic, for example, gets 36 mpg. But, when comparing prices – hybrids cost from $19,000 to $25,000 and gas saver cars cost $14,000 to $17,000.” Here the author explains the difference of prices between a hybrid car and a normal non-hybrid gas saver. Phillip Dunn also mentions that “the difference in average annual fuel bills – $405 for a Honda Insight versus $635 for a Honda Civic… Over a ten year period owning a hybrid you will save only $2,300.” I think that these figures say it all, buying a hybrid is only going to save hybrid owners $2,300. Some people look at this as being a large amount of money saved by owning a hybrid car.
Jim Walczak points out that “The first hybrid electric model in the U.S. market was the Honda Insight (61 mpg city, 70 mpg highway) in 1999.” This quote explains that hybrid vehicles aren’t even a decade old so this means that they are still fairly new to the automobile market.
Jim Walczak states “the idea with hybrid vehicles is to get the most fuel economy out of a smaller engine.” This is how hybrid cars are designed to work. Hybrid cars also have an electric motor to help out with the fuel economy which is what most people are aiming for with these outrageous gas prices. Jim Walczak also says “by combining topnotch fuel efficiencies and ultra-low tailpipe emissions, the end result is some of the cleanest and ‘greenest’ vehicles we’ve ever seen. As a whole, Hybrids deliver big-engine performance with small-engine fuel economy.” This informs us that hybrid cars don’t lose any power and they are still environment friendly.
Hybrid vehicles have a fairly low emissions output. Phillip Dunn states that “hybrid cars offer more than just great fuel economy, they offer many green advantages as well… Also, in large cities were pollution is at its worse, they make an even larger difference since they produce very little emissions during slow speed city driving and the inevitable traffic jams.” Low emissions output out of these hybrid cars help our environment a little bit better than a non-hybrid car. “Under acceleration, we found the Corolla, a conventional ICE vehicle, to be approximately 8.0 dBA louder than the hybrid vehicle, the Prius, when operating with its ICE (Wiener et al. 75).” This shows that hybrid vehicles are also quieter than a normal non-hybrid car. A quieter car can help with the environment and our noise pollution.
I put together a questionnaire and walked around IUP campus and asked college students what they knew about hybrid cars. This is my way of gathering information from a reliable source because it is first hand research gathered from IUP college students. I chose college students because college students are what my topic is mainly about. The questions I chose where important to me because these questions will help me better understand what IUP students know about hybrid cars and how they function. I chose a random sample of 30 IUP students in the Oak Grove. Most of the students that I asked knew what a hybrid car was, but when I asked if they knew how a hybrid car functions, 19 students said they knew how they functioned and replied by saying that they used electricity to run. Out of the 30 students that I asked, none of them owned a hybrid vehicle. For my next question I asked if they would ever buy a hybrid vehicle in the future. 24 IUP students out of 30 answered yes they would buy a hybrid car. Last but not least I asked why they would like to own a hybrid vehicle. The most common answer that I got was, to save money on gas because they get better gas mileage.
I also conducted an interview with a white female college student currently attending IUP. Danielle Scott is a junior majoring in sociology. My first question to her was; do you own a hybrid car? No. Are there any specific reasons why you don’t own a hybrid car? I don’t have money to buy a new car, especially spend the extra money on a hybrid car. Do you know what a hybrid car is and how they function? I have a basic idea of what a hybrid car is but I don’t know enough about them to know how they function and all the details about them. Do you currently have a job while attending college? Yes. What are your expenses like at college besides tuition? Car expenses, rent, and other bills such as cell phone and credit cards. Do your parents help you financially for your college education? No, they have not helped me in all of the years that I have been in college.
I put together a very small questionnaire and asked some IUP students about hybrid cars. The questionnaire can be found in Appendix A. I did expect most students to know what a hybrid vehicle was due to the fact that a lot of commercials have to do with hybrid vehicles and how much of a better gas mileage they get compared to normal gasoline cars. I was actually surprised by how many students knew how a hybrid car functioned. I didn’t expect that many IUP students to know how a hybrid car functions; I thought less people would know how they functioned. Before I started this questionnaire I had the feeling that nobody was going to answer yes when I asked if they owned a hybrid car. A couple of students did tell me that they might have a sibling that may own a hybrid vehicle but they didn’t own a hybrid car. Most of the students did tell me that they would like to own a hybrid vehicle in the future. I got the most common reason and it was exactly as I expected it to be. They want one mostly for better gas mileage because gas is too expensive these days.
Most people like to wait to see how a product is going to turn out before they buy it. I think that this is the case with hybrid vehicles and why people are still kind of skeptic of buying them. People still won’t buy them because they are still basically new and they don’t want to end up buying a car that is going to break down on them and is going to have technical problems. I think that the prices of these cars are still pretty high because of how new this line of vehicles is. I don’t think that car manufacturers have found any other cheaper ways of producing these hybrid vehicles. This is another reason why car owners aren’t buying these hybrid cars.
Some people are unaware of how environment friendly hybrids are and how they pollute less of our environment as opposed to normal gasoline cars that are still being driven today. There are fuel efficient vehicles in the automobile industry but the hybrid is even more fuel efficient than those cars due to the fact that they run on gasoline and can also run on battery which is the point of a hybrid car.
I don’t think that hybrid vehicles will ever diminish the sales of the normal gasoline cars that we drive today. It is known that hybrid cars get excellent gas mileage. Hybrid cars can get anywhere from 50 to 70 miles per gallon as opposed to a normal gasoline car that would normally get about 25 to almost 40 miles per gallon. Gas prices are high these days and a lot of people don’t exactly agree with them. There are several solutions to spending less money buying gas for cars like carpooling, public transportation or maybe even riding a bike to work, but some people are looking to invest into getting a hybrid car instead because of the fuel economy that they have to offer and how much less emissions output that they have as opposed to normal gasoline cars.
Hybrid cars just seem to be the new cool thing to have; for example new cell phones come out all the time and everybody wants to stay updated with the latest and nicer cell phone. People like the bells and whistles that these hybrid cars have to offer. Hybrid cars are slowly becoming more popular and I think it is due to the fact that the gas mileage is amazing on these cars.
My expectations were not exact compared to the results I got from my questionnaire. I was surprised by some of the results I got from at least two of the questions in my questionnaire. This research proved to me that not too many people drive hybrid cars at IUP. People would like to own them but they are too expensive and can’t afford them. This research also proved to me that many people know about hybrid cars but do not know how they function and what their purpose is. The interview I conducted with the IUP student helped me further determine that college students cannot afford buying a hybrid car. College students have other expenses to pay for and paying for a car and the insurance is out of the question.
The purpose of the hybrid car is mostly to save people gas and be environment friendly. Hybrid cars can be convenient when it comes to pumping gas but they can also be very expensive. Hybrid cars have a lot of technology incorporated into them and I believe that that’s what makes hybrid cars more expensive. Hybrid cars can be expensive when it comes to fixing them because they are new and there aren’t many mechanics that know how to fix these cars if something goes wrong with them.
Hybrid cars aren’t being driven by college students because we cannot afford them. They may be cheap when it comes to paying for gas but the money up front seems to be a little bit out of the question. They can also be expensive if they would break down with mechanical issues. I believe that if mechanical issues are taken care of by the car manufacturers more people will want to buy hybrid cars even though it seems like the tax break that buyers get is a good motivation to purchase a hybrid vehicle. There needs to be more positives about hybrid cars in order for people to want to buy them.
From personal experience I know that college is very expensive. During this research I have also learned that hybrid cars are expensive too. As a college student, all my college expenses do not allow me to purchase a hybrid car.
Appendix A
Questionnaire
- Do you know what a hybrid car is?
- Do you know how hybrid cars function?
- Do you own a hybrid car?
- Would you ever buy a hybrid car?
- Why would u like to own a hybrid car?
Appendix B
Abstract
The point of this research was to answer the question why college students don’t drive hybrid cars. I did research on the internet, put together a questionnaire and I also conducted an interview. This is significant because college students at IUP do not drive hybrid cars. It is also very significant because it is said that hybrid cars are better for our environment and they also save people money on gas. From my research I was able to conclude that college students don’t drive hybrid cars because they are expensive. Another reason why they do not drive hybrid cars is because college students have other expenses at school.
Works Cited
“America’s First Car.” The Southwest Michigan Directory.
<http://www.swmidirectory.org/Baushke_Car.html>
Asher, Kay. “Lessons from College Students on Living Frugally.” Helium.com 18 Mar.
2008
<http://www.helium.com/items/277241-college-students-notorious-always>
Dunn, Phillip. “Hybrid Cars – Pros and Cons.” PHYSORG. 2006
<http://www.physorg.com/news10031.html>
McCullough, Crystal. “Student Spending Habits, Debt are on the Increase.”
SMUdailycampus.com 4 Nov. 2005
<http://media.www.smudailycampus.com/media/storage/paper949/news/2005/11/
04/News/Student.Spending.Habits.Debt.Are.On.The.Increase-2276725.shtml>
Quiroga, Tony. “Green Machines.” Car and Driver. Jan. 2006
<http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/hot_lists/car_shopping/green_machines/h
onda_civic_hybrid_road_test+page-2.html>
Scott, Danielle. Personal interview. 1 Apr. 2008.
Walczak, Jim. “4-wheel drive/offroading.” About.com 25 Feb. 2008
<http://4wheeldrive.about.com/cs/buyacaronline/a/hybridcarstruck_2.htm
<http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/hybrid%20car>
Wiener, William, Naghshineh, Koorosh, Salisbury, Brad, and Rozema, Randall. The
impact of Hybrid Vehicles on Street Crossings. 2007
<http://web.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdf?vid=3&hid=112&sid=01d30dca-2117-4dcf-
b055-4cc39d64f8c4%40sessionmgr102>